Re: Cohousing communities with Sociocracy enshrined in Declaration / Bylaws? | <– Date –> <– Thread –> |
From: Sharon Villines (sharonsharonvillines.com) | |
Date: Tue, 31 Aug 2021 11:10:04 -0700 (PDT) |
> On Aug 31, 2021, at 12:45 PM, Abe Ross <cohoyote [at] gmail.com> wrote: > > I think the issue was not Sociocracy per se. It was about incorporating it > into the bylaws or declaration, etc. I realize that and I was awkward in explaining the problem. What is important is that the bylaws specify requirements for policy decisions — not to outline operational details. These can change. There may be developed a better way for some organizations to make decisions than in small circles, or example, or the linking of circles. Small circles are important when each circle has a unique aim and a defined set of members. But if many people have the same role, as in call centers, the circles might be much larger. Having small groups for the sake of small groups only fragments the membership. The important concept of a circle is that it is where all members make decisions as equals. This is rare. That people meet in small groups is not rare. That all levels of the organization make policy decisions is rare. It isn’t rare that the Operations Leader implements policies. Having an accepted authority is something I think will happen in the next few years. The original global authority in the Netherlands was very Dutch and very based in the engineering mindset. Every action had a solution expressed as a physics diagram. Americans, in particular, but many other cultures as well said this doesn’t feel like consent. Some groups split off from the global group and and some formed completely independently of the global group. So there are now several nodes of people who are developing new vocabularies and new examples that could be interpreted as contradicting each other. All call what they teach sociocracy. When writing bylaws, you don’t want to set up a situation where community members can cite different requirements of 'sociocracy.’ This has already happened with a homeowner in a community that was trying to adopting sociocratic methods, who said the bylaws say “consensus" decision-making, not sociocracy. All efforts to assure her that the distinction wasn’t meaningful failed to convince her that a lawsuit was not going to be productive. (I don’t know how it was resolved but at one point she was adamant and shopping around for authorities who would testify on her behalf. A personal grievance was at the base of the issue but personal grievances frequently hook onto technicalities that lead to court cases.) So how you include sociocracy depends on how you include it. Include the basic 3 principles or include the whole ball of wax in some form? According to this book? This teacher? This institute? Our just the “sociocratic principles and methods that support consent decision-making in policy decisions, egalitarian participation in policy decisions, distribution of power to all levels of the organization, etc.” The more general statement then allows you to modify day to day practices as long as they meet these requirements. Sharon ——— Sharon Villines, Editor & Publisher Affordable Housing means 30% of household income Cohousing means self-developed, self-governed, self-managed http://affordablecohousing.com
-
Cohousing communities with Sociocracy enshrined in Declaration / Bylaws? Scott Drennan, August 28 2021
- Re: Cohousing communities with Sociocracy enshrined in Declaration / Bylaws? Diana Leafe Christian, August 28 2021
-
Re: Cohousing communities with Sociocracy enshrined in Declaration / Bylaws? Sharon Villines, August 31 2021
-
Re: Cohousing communities with Sociocracy enshrined in Declaration / Bylaws? Abe Ross, August 31 2021
- Re: Cohousing communities with Sociocracy enshrined in Declaration / Bylaws? Sharon Villines, August 31 2021
- Re: Cohousing communities with Sociocracy enshrined in Declaration / Bylaws? Scott Drennan, August 31 2021
-
Re: Cohousing communities with Sociocracy enshrined in Declaration / Bylaws? Abe Ross, August 31 2021
-
Re: Cohousing communities with Sociocracy enshrined in Declaration / Bylaws? Sharon Villines, August 31 2021
-
Re: Cohousing communities with Sociocracy enshrined in Declaration / Bylaws? Brian Bartholomew, August 31 2021
- Re: Cohousing communities with Sociocracy enshrined in Declaration / Bylaws? Joyce Cheney, September 1 2021
-
Re: Cohousing communities with Sociocracy enshrined in Declaration / Bylaws? Brian Bartholomew, August 31 2021
Results generated by Tiger Technologies Web hosting using MHonArc.